A stadium can only do so many things at once, and on Sunday in Las Vegas thousands of people chose the smallest one: they sat. The Raiders lost 21-13 to Seattle, and Fernando Mendoza’s 10-yard touchdown run in the first quarter of his first career start was the one play anybody will carry out of the building. I think the reason is that thousands of fans stayed seated while cheering, and the sitting said more than a standing ovation could have.
Here is what that tells me about the audience. We are told, constantly, that the sports internet is a machine for outrage, and the machine’s output is real. But a crowd that is handed a way to be generous will take it faster than anyone running the machine seems to expect. Nobody had to be furious at anybody for this to move. That is the audience I recognize on a good day: people who would rather be useful than be right, if anyone shows them how.
A request with no villain in it
The gesture honored Mendoza’s mother, Elsa, who uses a wheelchair because of multiple sclerosis, diagnosed in 2008. Her seat was the point: when everyone else around her stayed down, the stadium matched her. The idea came from a fan named Tom Joanides, who asked for it on X on November 11.
https://x.com/TJoanides/status/2120309451421024735
The detail I can’t stop chewing on is that he had already asked once, months earlier, and almost nobody noticed.
https://x.com/TJoanides/status/2072314519112835295
Joanides’ July post got little traction. The November repost, five days before the game, drew more than 800,000 views and close to 400 reposts. Joanides told ESPN he has never had anything go viral before. Same man, same idea, same quarterback. What changed was the calendar. In July the touchdown was a hypothetical; by November it had a date, a seat in a stadium, and a game where fans needed something to do. My read is that a request travels when it is close enough to use, and by November this one was.
What fans want on a bad day
A loss gives fans nothing to hold. The scoreboard is the team’s property, and on a bad day it tells them only what they cannot fix. This request handed them a task they could finish themselves, in unison, with strangers, without a ticket upgrade or a sponsor. It cost nothing and needed everyone.
I’d argue that is what fans are hungry for from a team on its worst days. They can live without consolation and without a win if somebody gives them a role. Teams script their in-stadium engagement down to the second. The tribute that worked was one a fan typed on his phone.
Mendoza called the gesture a bright spot, saying, “On a dark day, that brings a smile to my face.” The cause has real money behind it as well: he gave $500,000 to the University of Miami’s health system and medical school to fight MS, and the Mendoza Family Fund, launched in April to support the National MS Society, has raised more than $1 million.
The cheap-gesture objection
The strongest case against all of this is that sitting down is free. Anyone can stay in a seat. A tribute that costs the crowd nothing is closer to a photo opportunity than an act, and the real money came from the quarterback and his family, not from the crowd.
That’s fair, and I’d still defend the cheapness. A gesture that demands sacrifice gets small participation; one that demands only agreement can fill a stadium. The ask was easy on purpose, and the easiness is what let thousands of people say yes at the same instant.
Mendoza’s road to this start has had plenty of noise of its own, from the QB1 question before camp to the pick-six that did not cost him his spot. The sitting on Sunday came from one person’s ask, small enough that thousands of strangers could say yes without a second thought.
The next ask like this will come from a stranger with a phone and a good idea. The only question is whether the team will have the sense to stay out of its way.