“Like his personality.” That is the loudest thing Nick Sirianni said about his quarterback coming out of the bye, and I’m furious about it. The Eagles are 2-7 with seven straight losses, Joe Milton keeps the job, Sean Mannion keeps the playcalling, and the explanation on offer is that Milton tries hard. Hard work is the price of admission to an NFL locker room. Nobody gets a roster spot without it, and nobody ever won a game with it alone.
Here is the full quote, from ESPN’s report on the decision: “He works extremely hard with everything, really love his approach, like his personality.” Then, a beat later: “He’s a really hard worker, and I really value that.”
Great. Now look at what that hard worker was handed, and what it cost him. In the Giants game, his first career start, Milton went 18-of-34 for 169 yards with no touchdowns and took seven sacks, one of them with a fumble, in a 19-11 loss. He also ran nine times for 64 yards, and I read that as a quarterback bailing out of pockets that kept collapsing. A guy signed off Dallas’s practice squad absorbed seven sacks in his first start, got up after each one, and his reward is a pat on the head. Milton is the person this costs. He is the one who has to take the next snap behind whatever the plan turns out to be, and he deserves a coach who can describe it.
https://x.com/JClarkNBCS/status/2123106846416179455
Mannion, a first-year coordinator, keeps the calls. Think about how that sounds in a building where the offense is among the league’s worst. Standing pat is a decision, and it is a decision that gets made by the people who will not be the ones getting hit. Sirianni’s case for that, as NBC Sports Philadelphia quoted him, is that Mannion is “really smart” with “a great football mind.” Smart is a fine thing to be, and smart is cheap in a football building. It also describes a lot of people who have never run an offense that ranks last in yards and 30th in scoring.
To be fair to Sirianni, he did not pretend everything is fine. He said, “Obviously, we haven’t been good enough on offense but I like our plan of attack and our process.” That sentence deserves a closer look, because it is the whole problem. He likes the plan. The plan produced seven straight losses. And in everything reported from that press conference, I can find nothing in the plan that changes. He did not name a single piece of it that will be different on Sunday. You can like a plan all you want. When it has gone 2-7, liking it is a hobby.
I’ll grant the strongest version of his defense. Jalen Hurts is out for the season, and a bye is one week, which is not much time to rebuild an offense around a quarterback who came off another team’s practice squad. A coordinator in that spot has few tools, and patience with a first-year playcaller is not crazy on its face. I’d buy all of it from a coach who could name one adjustment, one route concept, one protection fix, one anything that gives Milton a better shot than the last one did. Even a small answer would count. A coach who names nothing is telling a quarterback and a city to wait and hope.
Instead the answer is continuity, and continuity is a word coaches use when they would rather not say “we are doing the same thing.” It was already a staff drawing questions after Sirianni’s clock management in London. Now the offense is the same group, the same calls, and the same quarterback behind the same protection, going into a Sunday against the Steelers at 6-3.
That is the damn problem with praising effort: effort is the one thing everybody on the field already has. A coach’s job starts where effort runs out, with the protection calls, the quick throws, the script for the first fifteen plays, and the nerve to change one of them when the old version is 2-7.
“Like his personality” is a press conference answer. Somebody in that building owes Joe Milton a plan to go with the praise.