Jacksonville is 7-2, and the Jaguars’ point differential of +125 through nine games is the best in the league. Treating that as a pleasant surprise misreads it. Split the number into scoring, turnovers and depth, and each piece holds up on its own, which is what a complete team looks like and a lucky one does not.
ESPN’s Michael DiRocco put the +125 in context after the 40-23 win over the Titans: it is the most through nine games since the 2021 Bills, who sat at +145 at the same point. Here is the framework for reading it.
Are the Jaguars actually a Super Bowl contender?
Yes, on the evidence so far. ESPN’s FPI gives Jacksonville the third-best odds in the league to make and win the Super Bowl. The Jaguars also have five wins by 17 or more points, the most in the NFL, with Buffalo second at three. That is not certainty, but it is a profile contenders share.
What does a +125 point differential look like split apart?
It looks like three separate engines: scoring, turnovers and depth. Pull them apart and you can see whether any one of them is carrying the rest.
Scoring. Jacksonville has not scored fewer than 30 points in over a month. Trevor Lawrence threw for 352 yards and three touchdowns against Tennessee, tying Blake Bortles’ franchise record of seven games with 300-plus yards and three or more touchdown passes. He has 21 touchdown passes, on pace for 40, and Bortles’ single-season record is 35.
The zoom-out is better still. Since Week 11 of 2025, Lawrence has 40 touchdown passes, an NFL-best 45 total touchdowns and the third-best Total QBR at 74.5, and Jacksonville is 15-2 in that span. Both losses came on the road, in Denver and in London.
The scoring is also spread out. Parker Washington set a career high with 152 receiving yards, 148 of them in the first half, plus a touchdown. Josh Cameron and Brenton Strange scored too, and six players now have multiple touchdown catches. The offense does not lean on one receiver.
Turnovers. The defense has forced at least one turnover in eight of nine games and owns a league-best +9 turnover margin. Jacksonville has scored 71 points off turnovers, second only to Green Bay’s 74. That is a real chunk of the +125, and it is also the piece most likely to cool.
Depth. Underneath the takeaways, the defense is second in scoring defense at 16 points per game and sixth against the run at 91 yards per game. The defense gives up few points and little ground on the run, with or without the takeaways.
Does the defense have a second gear?
It might, because the +125 was built almost entirely before the reload. Last Monday Jacksonville added defensive tackles Jordan Davis and Davon Godchaux and traded for Jessie Bates III. Davis and Bates did not play Sunday, because they had not yet had a bye week.
https://x.com/jlbiii3/status/2119785474378371139
Davis and Godchaux help replace DaVon Hamilton, who is out for the season. Bates fills the spot of Eric Murray, who is out with an elbow injury. So the headline defensive numbers come mostly from the group that was there before those three arrived. Whatever they add comes on top of a differential already ahead of everyone.
The best argument against
The strongest counterargument has three parts. Turnover margin tends to regress, and a +9 is the part of this profile that leans most on luck. FPI is a model, and a model gives you odds, not a trophy. And one blowout over the Titans is a single data point on a nine-game sample.
All fair. Here is why the take still holds. Set the turnover points aside and the offense still has a quarterback with the third-best Total QBR since Week 11 of 2025 and six players with multiple touchdown catches. On defense, the second-ranked scoring unit and the sixth-ranked run defense do not depend on takeaways. Regression would shave the margin. It would not erase it.
The 15-2 stretch is the strongest sign of all, because it spans parts of two seasons. Teams that are only lucky rarely hold that pace for that long.
Where this leaves the Jaguars
Nine games is not a season, and nothing here guarantees January. Coach Liam Coen said of his quarterback, “Can’t say enough about how he’s playing right now.” Lawrence described it more simply: “I just have a lot of comfort in what we’re doing.”
Comfort tends to show up in the math before it shows up in the conversation. The math is already in.