Pat McAfee and Kirk Herbstreit picked SMU on GameDay, and Wake Forest answered by putting 42 points on the Mustangs before halftime on the way to a 49-7 win in Dallas. The apology came less than two hours after the show ended, in a video on Herbstreit’s own account.
https://x.com/KirkHerbstreit/status/2121675349243355185
McAfee’s contribution was three words: “That’s on us.” Herbstreit said they were wrong and that Wake is legitimate. Two guys who get paid to be confident reversed themselves faster than most people finish lunch.
Now the committee has a Tuesday to fill. Wake Forest is 9-1 and was ranked 13th last week. Before Saturday, at 8-1, the Deacons sat behind four teams with two losses apiece, which tells you how the room was reading them: nice story, wait and see. Saturday was the wait and see. Gio Lopez threw three touchdown passes, and the game was over at the break.
Take a step back from the one night and the pattern is uglier for everyone who doubted them. ESPN reports Wake is the first team since 2013 Alabama to post four straight first-half shutouts while scoring at least 20 before halftime. ESPN also has the Deacons outscoring opponents 145-0 across those eight first-half quarters. Since Oct. 1 they lead the FBS in scoring margin at +44.8 points per game, and they own the No. 4 scoring offense in the country plus the ACC’s best scoring defense at 15.0 points a game.
That profile does not belong at 13. I made a version of this argument when the earlier rankings came out, and the numbers since have only made it easier. Wake is the team whose résumé keeps stacking up in a season that already gave us a chaotic Saturday or two.
The strongest counterargument is simple: SMU was unranked, and one blowout of an unranked team shouldn’t rewrite a résumé. Fair. Nobody should be asking the committee to react to a single game. The ask is smaller than that. Look at eight straight quarters of shutout football, the best scoring margin in the FBS since Oct. 1, and a loss column with one entry in it. That is the whole case, and Saturday only happened to put a bow on it.
The media already did the humbling part, on camera, inside two hours. The committee gets to do it quietly, with a number. Move Wake Forest up Tuesday, because ESPN is already eyeing a likely Miami rematch in the ACC title game, and the Deacons should walk into that game ranked like they belong in it.