The Colts held onto Daniel Jones through a deadline where they were shipping out former Pro Bowlers for draft picks, then released him two games later, and I cannot make either decision look smart no matter which angle I try.

Start with the deadline. Indianapolis moved on from multiple former Pro Bowlers for picks, and Jones was considered a possible trade candidate. The Colts kept him anyway. By the end, ESPN Research had him last among 31 QBR-qualified quarterbacks in Total QBR (29.1), yards per attempt (5.6) and yards per dropback (4.8), with a league-high 13 interceptions to go with 7 touchdowns and 1,974 yards. That is the quarterback the front office chose over the assets it was busy selling.

Then came Thursday night. A 26-3 loss to the Texans, Jones 12-for-27 for 144 yards and an interception, and he got pulled before the end. Anthony Richardson Sr. entered with roughly seven minutes left and didn’t complete a pass. By Friday, Shane Steichen was announcing the release, per the Colts’ own post.

https://x.com/Colts/status/2123840077621002272

Steichen’s send-off was gracious. Jones was an “ultimate competitor, ultimate teammate” who “gave this organization everything he had.” Fine. Nobody is accusing the man of loafing. The question is about the people who signed him to a two-year, $88 million deal in March, with $50 million fully guaranteed at signing, and then needed eight months to reach a conclusion the stat sheet had reached long before.

Here is the logic problem, and it only runs two ways. If the Colts knew by the deadline that Jones was done, then keeping him bought nothing, because the guarantee was owed either way and the deadline was the one chance to get anything back. If they didn’t know until Thursday, then they watched a team sink to 3-8, with six losses in its last seven, and learned nothing until a blowout forced the issue. Pick one. Both are an indictment of whoever made the call.

The strongest defense is the obvious one. That $50 million is gone whether Jones is cut in November or kept through January, so releasing him now is just sunk cost finally written down. And maybe nobody was going to give up anything for a quarterback with those numbers. I’ll give them that much. It still doesn’t explain why the deadline looked like a fire sale for everybody except the one player whose contract was the biggest mistake on the roster. If a trade market for him didn’t exist, say so. If it did, they passed.

Swipe already ran a piece on Steichen refusing to bench Jones, and the stubbornness there at least had the virtue of being consistent. This is the bill for that consistency. A coach loyal to his quarterback is one thing, but the people above him had the whole deadline to get out in front of this, and the losing was already a story here in September.

Somebody should say who pays for the delay. Anthony Richardson Sr. gets the start on Nov. 29 against the Giants, inheriting a 3-8 season with nothing left to save. That’s a shit way to run a franchise, and a gracious send-off is no substitute for an explanation.

The people who spent a deadline avoiding this decision are still the ones running the building.