Forty-one players have run an offense this hard and none of them won a championship that season. Luka Doncic is running it harder than all but two of them, and that is the number the Lakers should be worried about after the loss in Utah. My take: the Lakers cannot win a title on the current workload, so their season rests on Luka breaking a pattern nobody has broken, or on finding him a second creator.

What does a 40.4 usage rate actually measure?

Usage rate measures how much of an offense runs through one player. Doncic’s 40.4 is the third-highest in a season since tracking began in 1967, according to ESPN’s Ben Golliver. Only Russell Westbrook’s 41.7 in 2016-17 and James Harden’s 40.5 in 2018-19 sit above it.

This is not a new habit for him. Golliver notes that Doncic’s 2022-23 season (37.6) and 2025-26 season (38.1) both rank in the all-time top 10. Put those together with this year and you get one player who owns three of the ten heaviest workloads the league has ever tracked, and the season he is in now is the heaviest of the three.

Has anyone this high ever won a title?

No. Golliver found that 41 players have posted a usage rate above 35.0 in a season, and none of them won the championship that year. The list reads like a hall of fame ballot: Jordan, Iverson, Bryant, Wade, Harden, Westbrook, Antetokounmpo, Embiid.

The champions cluster lower. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander’s 34.8 in 2025 is the highest usage rate for a title winner since 1967, which means the ceiling for a champion sits below the floor of that 41-player group.

The all-timers tell the same story with their own résumés. Jordan’s usage peaked at 38.3 in 1986-87, when the Bulls were swept in the first round. In his six title seasons it ran between 31.7 and 34.7. Kobe Bryant peaked at 38.7 in 2005-06, a first-round loss for the Lakers, then won with 32.2 and 32.3 in 2008-09 and 2009-10. LeBron James hit his career high of 33.8 in 2008-09, and the Cavaliers lost in the East finals. His four titles came at 30.2 to 32.0.

Read that as a pattern across eras, not a coincidence. Every one of those players got better results when the offense asked a little less of him. Doncic’s deepest run, the 2024 Finals, came at 36.0, well below where he is now.

The two cases closest to his are worth a look. Westbrook led the league in scoring and won MVP in 2016-17, then lost to Houston in five games in the first round. Harden’s Rockets won 53 games in 2018-19 and averaged 36.1 points, and Golden State beat them in six in the second round. Huge usage, huge individual seasons, early exits.

Does the counterargument change the answer?

The best case against me comes from two places. JJ Redick said he does not believe in usage rate and prefers what he calls “true usage,” meaning time with the ball in your hands. By that measure Doncic ranks fourth in the league at 9.4 minutes of possession per game through Tuesday, and he called Doncic’s usage a non-issue.

The efficiency argument is stronger. Doncic is posting a 64.4 true shooting mark this season. Westbrook’s was 55.4 in his 2016-17 season. Harden’s was 61.6 in 2018-19. Doncic is giving the Lakers far more per possession than either of those two did, and a fair reader will ask why the same warning should apply.

It holds anyway. Efficiency tells you how well a player spends the possessions he takes. It does not tell you what a defense does in May, when it knows exactly who is taking them. Harden was good enough to put up 61.6 and still lost to Golden State. And Redick himself, after the Utah Jazz beat the Lakers 109-97 to end a nine-game win streak, said the shot creation required from Doncic “takes its toll.” That sentence came from the coach who dismisses the stat, in a game where Doncic went 10-of-28 with nine turnovers, according to ESPN’s reporting on the loss.

https://x.com/mcten/status/2123299078805369029

A star who takes that much blame after one bad night is also telling you how much of the team he believes is his to carry. That belief is the whole problem, and no coaching comment about “true usage” makes it smaller.

Can the Lakers add a second creator?

They have to, and the cost is smaller than it sounds. The Lakers do not need a second Luka. They need someone who can run a possession for ten minutes a night so Doncic can spend them off the ball, because Jordan, Bryant and LeBron each ran lighter in their title years than in their heaviest ones. Jordan’s six championship seasons never topped 34.7, and his sweep-year peak was 38.3.

That is a roster question before it is a Doncic question. The Lakers’ bench depth problem already shows how thin the supporting group gets when Luka sits, and it is the most obvious place to start. Giannis called him the best scorer ever, and that is exactly why the answer cannot be to ask him to score more.

The highest usage any champion has carried is 34.8. Doncic is at 40.4, a gap of 5.6 points that either closes through a second creator or stays open and tests the pattern again. Los Angeles has until spring to decide which.